Current:Home > MyFederal judge denies Trump's bid for new trial in E. Jean Carroll case-InfoLens
Federal judge denies Trump's bid for new trial in E. Jean Carroll case
View Date:2024-12-23 19:46:57
A federal judge has denied former President Donald Trump's request for a new trial in the civil suit brought by the writer E. Jean Carroll, who was awarded an $83.3 million judgment by a jury that found Trump liable for defamation in January.
The judge also denied a request to strike the damages in the case, which Trump had called "entirely out of proportion" with Carroll's reputational injury.
"Mr. Trump's argument is entirely without merit both as a matter of law and as a matter of fact," U.S. District Judge Lewis Kaplan wrote in an 18-page decision Thursday.
Roberta Kaplan, an attorney for Carroll who is unrelated to the judge, said she is "pleased with though not surprised by" the decision.
"It was entirely reasonable for the jury to award E. Jean Carroll $83 million in damages given Donald Trump's continued defamation of Ms. Carroll during the trial itself, as well as his conduct in the courtroom where his 'hatred and disdain [were] on full display,'" Kaplan said, quoting the judge's decision.
An attorney for Trump said he intends to appeal the decision.
"We categorically disagree with Judge Kaplan's decision," said Alina Habba. "It ignores long-standing constitutional principles and is a prime example of the lawfare raging across this country. We are confident that this decision will be overturned by the Second Circuit."
Trump requested the new trial in a March filing that listed grievances about the trial and pretrial decisions, including the exclusion of evidence related to Trump's "state of mind" when he defamed Carroll.
A longtime advice columnist, Carroll wrote a story in New York magazine in 2019 accusing Trump of sexually assaulting her in a department store dressing room in the mid-1990s.
Trump, who was president when the story was published, denied the allegations, calling Carroll a "whack job" and claiming he had never met her.
He claimed in his March filing that the jury couldn't have reasonably concluded Carroll suffered damages as a result of his comments, because they were made five hours after the story was published. Trump's attorneys pointed to a trickle of negative feedback Carroll received during that "five-hour gap." Carroll's attorneys said she was subject to a sustained deluge of derision and threats after Trump weighed in.
Trump claimed the jury's findings were based on "'confusion, speculation or prejudice' as opposed to the 'evidence presented at trial.'"
Kaplan wrote that Trump's argument ignored that the jury and court concluded the statements Trump was sued over "were false, defamatory, and made with both actual and common law malice."
"It ignores the fact that those defamatory statements were viewed between at least 85 to 104 million times," Kaplan wrote.
Graham KatesGraham Kates is an investigative reporter covering criminal justice, privacy issues and information security for CBS News Digital. Contact Graham at [email protected] or [email protected]
veryGood! (66549)
Related
- Record-setting dry conditions threaten more US wildfires, drinking water supplies
- Videos put scrutiny on downed power lines as possible cause of deadly Maui wildfires
- Don’t Miss These Rare 50% Off Deals on Le Creuset Cookware
- Pet daycare flooding kills several dogs in Washington DC; Firefighter calls staff heroes
- Mega Millions winning numbers for November 8 drawing: Jackpot rises to $361 million
- The Bold Type's Katie Stevens Details Suffering Panic Attacks During Postpartum Depression Journey
- These 7 Las Vegas resorts had bedbugs over the last 18 months
- Will Donald Trump show up at next week’s presidential debate? GOP rivals are preparing for it
- Judith Jamison, acclaimed Alvin Ailey American dancer and director, dead at 81
- Spain vs. Sweden in 2023 World Cup soccer semifinal: Time, channel, how to watch
Ranking
- How Kim Kardashian Navigates “Uncomfortable” Situations With Her 4 Kids
- Trump indicted on 2020 election fraud charges in Georgia, Lahaina fire update: 5 Things podcast
- Russia targets western Ukraine with missiles overnight and hits civilian infrastructure
- Halle Berry has Barbie-themed 57th birthday with 'no so mini anymore' daughter Nahla
- Stock market today: Asian shares meander, tracking Wall Street’s mixed finish as dollar surges
- UN chief urges deployment of police special forces and military support to combat gangs in Haiti
- University presidents elevate free speech under new partnership
- Dark circles under the eyes are common. Here's how to get rid of them.
Recommendation
-
Ex-Marine misused a combat technique in fatal chokehold of NYC subway rider, trainer testifies
-
'Chrisley Knows Best' family announces new reality TV show amid Todd and Julie's prison sentences
-
Pacific Northwest heat wave could break temperature records through Thursday
-
Selena Gomez Has the Last Laugh After Her Blanket Photo Inspires Viral Memes
-
How Kim Kardashian Navigates “Uncomfortable” Situations With Her 4 Kids
-
Lithium-ion battery fires from electric cars, bikes and scooters are on the rise. Are firefighters ready?
-
Why tensions have been growing along NATO’s eastern border with Belarus
-
US launches program to provide electricity to more Native American homes